Why Customers Defect

October 31st, 2009

Guest blog by Mary Sullivan of KickStart Alliance

You’ve heard the adage, “It costs five times as much to attract a new customer as it does to retain an old one.” Even if you question the multiplier number, you know the concept is valid. And yet, businesses don’t always realize when former customers have decided not to buy from them again.

One possible clue: sales are down. Granted, in a recession most everyone’s sales are down, but this is not a time to get complacent. Another clue: people are bad-mouthing your business online. How would you know that’s happening? There are many tools that allow you to monitor whether anyone is talking about you on social networks.

Customers decide not to come back to a business when they have expectations that the business, service or product are not fulfilling. Invariably, they find an alternative. There goes somebody’s market share.

The trick is to learn what customers expect of your business in advance of their departure. Next, ask them how well you’re meeting those expectations, and implement changes that will keep them on board. Best to ask before they go, but if it’s too late and they’re gone, ask anyway.

I recently wrapped up a project for a business services company to help them uncover reasons for a fairly high customer defection rate. They knew a few of their small business customers had ceased operations when the economy took a nosedive. But they wondered what else might be wrong.

We pulled a list of customers that had left during the last year and undertook to interview as many of them as we could. We offered to make a generous donation to a nationwide health organization in the name of each business that granted us a 10-minute interview. Some contacts just weren’t reachable after multiple calls, so we sent out a survey to those.

Nearly 25% of the former customers did participate in an interview, and over 8% responded to the online survey. The results were both predictable and surprising, in turns. They had anticipated that some customers were upset by a price increase that occurred when the recession started. But they hadn’t realized that their one-size-fits-all bundle of services really didn’t work for everyone. Patterns emerged, and profiles of several different types of offerings that customers wanted became evident.

Better than finding out why they’ve gone, take active steps now to understand your customers’ expectations while they are still with you.

  • Set up a social media-monitoring tool to alert you if people are posting comments about your business online. Identify someone in your organization to track and respond promptly to both positive and negative comments.
  • Invite key decision-makers to a customer advisory board meeting. If possible, bring in an independent facilitator, and hold the meeting to a preset agenda that is relevant to the attendees.
  • Encourage product management and marketing people to meet with a few different customers semi-annually to discuss how they are using what you offer, what they like, and what’s missing.
  • Conduct a survey to determine what is important to your customers. Ask someone who is not so close to your business to help you frame the questions. Provide respondents the option to give more detailed, off-script comments.
  • When you gain insight into what you can do to be a better partner to your customers, make it happen.


If you did this last year, that’s good! Now, it’s time to do it again. Customers’ needs change. Just remember, it may “cost you five times more” if you don’t keep taking their temperature.

Mary Sullivan is a co-founder of KickStart Alliance, a team of marketing and sales consultants to B2B technology companies, including clean tech. Mary started her career in tech in sales and later moved to product management and product marketing, bringing her affinity for the customer with her. Increasingly, her focus is on online and social marketing and the value of the content that can enrich businesses’ relationships with their customers.


One Response to “Why Customers Defect”

  1. Russ A. Hatfield Jr.

    Great reminder, Mary, that a defected (ex-)customer can offer a wealth of insight into your business. To not re-engage them — even some defined segment of them — is simply insane, especially in this economy.

    You said: “Identify someone in your organization to track and respond promptly to both positive and negative comments.” I agree with this. Though, I would emphasize the need to put some thought into just HOW you will be responding. If you’re going to engage these customers via social media you need to be ready to act on at least some portion of the responses — even if it’s to effectively say “We’re sorry, but we can’t do anything about that”. To have failed them once is bad…but to deliberately seek their thoughts out and then to not follow-through at all is even worse. If you’re going to ask “Why did you leave”, “How did we not satisfy you?” or something similar, be ready to respond.

    Also, among your suggestions for ways to “understand your customers’ expectations while they are still with you” — all of which are great! — I would add the regular gathering and analysis of information from your call center, customer service, technical support or similar post-sales contact centers. 99% of contacts to these functional areas are because something went wrong, is not working, etc. It’s a GREAT and proactive way to see where the friction and pain-points are for your customers WHILE they are still customers. Build self-help, FAQs to get some quick wins, and integrate this feedback into the product development/R&D process to design resolutions(fixes) directly into the next version of your product.

    Great actionable thoughts, Mary.

    Thanks!
    Russ
    Seattle, WA
    http:///www.twitter.com/russhatfield

Leave a Reply

/ home / customer insight / services / typical applications / why the insight advantage? /

/ background / resources and links / workshops and speeches / contact us

Website by The Web Mechanic.
Copyright © The Insight Advantage. All rights reserved.